The Budget debate concluded and the Appropriation (2016/17 Estimates) Bill was read a second time.
Ayes 63 (National 59, Maori Party 2, ACT 1, United Future 1)
Noes 58 (Labour 32, Greens 14, NZ First 12)
Labour leader Andrew Little’s motion of no confidence in the Government was defeated by 63 votes to 58.